What makes a good expert reviewer for AI evaluation in clinical trial operations?
A good expert reviewer is a practitioner who does the work being tested, such as a coordinator, monitor or investigator, and rates each item independently against a written rubric tied to ICH E6(R3).
A rating counts only after several independent reviewers have rated the item, and clinical research professionals can offer to rate our items through the reviewer request form.
What makes a reviewer qualified
- They do, or recently did, the role the item is about, because trials need people qualified by education, training and experience for their tasks (ICH E6(R3) Principle 5).
- They know the current guideline, ICH E6(R3), and the rules where they work.
- They did not write the item they are rating, and they say so if they have a conflict.
- They rate against the rubric, not against how their own site happens to do things.
How expert review of AI evaluation items works
- Each item is a realistic trial situation with several plausible responses.
- Each reviewer rates the item on their own, without seeing other ratings.
- An item settles only when three or more independent professionals have rated it, and items where reviewers disagree go back for revision.
- Reviewers are counted, never named, unless they choose to be listed.
- The same items are then answered by AI models and by practitioners, so a model's score can be compared with people who do the work.
Why AI evaluation needs practitioners, not only an answer key
In trial operations, more than one response can be defensible and some wrong answers are far more harmful than others. An answer key written by one organization is that organization's opinion. Independent ratings from people who do the work are what make an evaluation item something others can trust, which is also why FDA's draft guidance asks that an AI model's credibility be shown for a defined context of use (FDA draft guidance on AI, January 2025).
How to offer to review
If you work in clinical research, tell us your role, organization and experience on the reviewer request form. A person reads every request. Once your request is accepted, you receive a private review link by email, and no account is needed.
Questions people also ask
Who can review CRLN's assessment items?
People who work in clinical research, such as coordinators, research nurses, monitors, investigators and quality staff. A person reads each request before a review link is sent.
Will my name be shown?
Only if you choose. Reviewers are counted, never named, unless they agree to be listed with the details they pick, and they can withdraw at any time.
Does reviewing items mean I endorse CRLN?
No. A reviewer rates items. Being listed shows that you reviewed items, not that you endorse CRLN or anything it publishes.
How many reviewers does an item need?
An item settles only when three or more independent professionals have rated it. The live count, by role, is on the validation ledger.
Primary sources
- ICH E6(R3) Guideline for Good Clinical Practice, final version adopted 6 January 2025 (ICH): https://database.ich.org/sites/default/files/ICH_E6%28R3%29_Step4_FinalGuideline_2025_0106.pdf
- Considerations for the Use of Artificial Intelligence to Support Regulatory Decision-Making for Drug and Biological Products, draft guidance (FDA): https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/considerations-use-artificial-intelligence-support-regulatory-decision-making-drug-and-biological
Last reviewed
2026-11-14